AND a yr in the past, IRM Company despatched letters to greater than 1,500 traders, together with Jim and Bertha VanderKodde of Grand Rapids, Michigan. The letter acknowledged that IRM – Funding Analysis Administration – can’t make any additional funds.
“Once we bought that letter,” Jim VanderKodde instructed CT, “we stated, 'The Lord gave it to us and the Lord took it from us.' We by no means misplaced a watch over it.”
For the VanderKoddes, the funding totaled $10,000, a comparatively small portion of their financial savings after he retired from a 28-year profession as a police officer. However for a lot of different traders in IRM's $400 million actual property operation, sleep hasn't come so simply. Many are retirees who’ve invested most or all of their life financial savings in a non-public firm.
IRM founder John O. Van Hofwegen and most of its traders are members of the Grand Rapids-based Christian Reformed Church (CRC). The CRC is without doubt one of the fundamental inheritors of the Dutch Calvinist custom in North America. The corporate's star salesman, Jay Merron, beforehand taught at CRC-affiliated South Christian Excessive College in Grand Rapids. Along with tons of of particular person traders, a number of the largest businesses related to the CRC, the House Missions Board, Calvin School and Again to the hour of God the radio ministry invested a complete of $11.4 million in IRM. The Barnabas Basis, one other main investor, though non-denominational, has many CRC shoppers. Potential losses for all events may exceed $130 million.
CALIFORNIA CONNECTION: IRM started as a property administration restricted partnership within the late Sixties and finally acquired 59 properties, principally condominium complexes in Northern and Central California. For greater than 20 years, IRM has paid traders dividends of 9 to 11 p.c.
Within the late Eighties, nevertheless, two components began IRM down a troubled path. First, Congress modified the tax legal guidelines on restricted partnerships, making them much less enticing as investments. Second, and extra ominously, the underside fell out of California's as soon as booming actual property market.
What occurred subsequent is a matter of dispute. IRM “defrauded traders out of greater than $100 million,” CRC CFO Ken Horjus stated in a court docket submitting. A lawsuit filed in July by a gaggle of CRC businesses and particular person traders accused IRM of operating a “Ponzi” operation that “created and sustained an actual property funding pyramid scheme.”
Not so, insists John Barnard, an actual property turnaround lawyer employed by IRM administration final winter. “There isn’t any Ponzi or pyramid scheme right here,” he instructed CT, solely after a sequence of enterprise reversals ensuing from a mixture of the true property recession, excessive rates of interest and financing issues. He notes that the Van Hofwegen household additionally had a majority of their fairness within the firm in danger, which isn’t the case in intentionally fraudulent schemes.
GUILT TO BE AROUND: Regardless of these assurances, a number of extra lawsuits adopted, and in August IRM filed for Chapter 11 chapter safety. Regulatory businesses in each California and Michigan opened investigations into IRM's actions.
Barnard stays hopeful {that a} purchaser shall be discovered for the IRM properties and that the sale will recuperate most or the entire capital, significantly from smaller traders.
Jim VanderKodde is just not so optimistic. “It's not possible we'll ever get our a reimbursement,” he says. VanderKodde doesn't see IRM administration as flawed. “They only screwed up and misplaced cash. I don't really feel any bitterness in the direction of anybody.”
Others are usually not so calm. Many imagine that IRM may have averted chapter if the CRC businesses had not insisted on authorized motion. They have been indignant after they realized that church businesses and the Barnabas Basis had been lowering funding in IRM previous to October 1997. CRC officers didn’t assist their trigger after they responded to the IRM letter by imposing a “no remark” order on all employees, together with the denominational journal, Banner. The order was lifted after protests and the publication of leaked inner denominational paperwork on the Web. In June, the denominational synod prolonged its session by sooner or later to listen to from CKR employees concerning the IRM scenario.
The Barnabas Basis, a monetary advisory agency in Orland Park, Unwell., with 168 consumer teams — principally CRC-related — has additionally been criticized. However managing director David Vander Ploeg says he and others merely did the “due diligence” they owed their shoppers. Vander Ploeg says the inspiration found IRM's monetary mess throughout routine audits within the early Nineteen Nineties, and the cuts have been merely accountable fiduciary administration.
LEVEL LANDING: A way of resentment amongst many small traders was heightened when Christian Reformed Church officers earlier this yr opposed a Grand Rapids businessman's provide to purchase IRM's liabilities at 5 cents on the greenback. CRC officers say they felt they may discover a higher deal. However tons of of traders who flocked to conferences in Michigan and California over the summer season tied up denominational cellphone and fax traces to protest plans for a lawsuit and demand the deal be accepted.
Leaders of the Christian Reformed Church have additionally come beneath fireplace for ignoring biblical directions for Christians to keep away from suing each other. CRC Ministries Director Peter Borgdorff responded in a July letter to traders: “This can be a tragic misuse of Scripture. In fact, it’s true that we must always not search to make use of the legislation in an adversarial method. However there is no such thing as a biblical admonition that prohibits us from looking for the rule of legislation and the safety of the courts when such authorities and safety is urgently wanted.”
In August, the court docket authorised an 11-member collectors' committee to think about new bids for IRM. Its chairman is Grand Rapids businessman Jay Mol, who says he’s the biggest particular person investor in IRM. Since his appointment, Mol has fielded distressed calls from distressed particular person traders, attempting to determine who’re merely dealing with “misery” versus those that are in “dire misery”.
In the meantime, VanderKodde isn't too involved concerning the destiny of IRM. “I do numerous volunteering in hurricane and twister aid,” he says. “I’ll proceed to do that so long as the Lord permits me to.”
Copyright © 1998 Christianity At the moment. Click on for reprint info.
Do you wish to add one thing to this? See one thing we missed? Share your opinion right here.
