“Can you’re keen on your neighbor as your self and on the identical time kneel him within the face as onerous as you may?” American combined martial arts (MMA) champion Scott “Bam Bam” Sullivan wonders in an interview with The Occasions (London).
At the moment, greater than 700 evangelical church buildings within the US combine MMA (also called cage combating) into their ministry applications. The phenomenon was even featured within the latest 2014 documentary Combat Church.
MMA is a mixture of kickboxing, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Greco-Roman wrestling and Thai boxing. Fighters face one another and brutally inflict ache by punching, kicking, kneeing and elbowing their opponents into submission. The depth of violence within the sport has brought on Senator John McCain to name for a whole ban on MMA within the US. He condemned it as “human cockfighting”, a “blood sport” and a “blood tub”.
Making the church masculine
The notion that MMA and Christianity are appropriate bedfellows is loosely based mostly on the ideology of Muscular Christianity, a predominantly male Victorian-era motion that related the gospel with bodily and psychological endurance. The motion's two leaders – Charles Kingsley, a priest and scholar, and Thomas Hughes, a well-known Victorian-era writer (and boxing coach) – sought to counter the perceived feminization of the church and entice males to the religion.
A muscular Christian ethos underpinned the beginning of contemporary sport, significantly in British public faculties within the late nineteenth century. Nonetheless, there was a big decline within the institutional connection between sport and religion, which lasted till the Nineteen Fifties. Then Protestant Christian leaders like Billy Graham noticed sports activities as a possible evangelistic software and re-invigorated its promotion within the church.
Because the mid-Twentieth century, quite a few sports activities organizations have been fashioned, such because the Fellowship of Christian Sportsmen within the USA and Christians in Sport in Nice Britain.
Wikimedia Commons
Like their Victorian forebears, these organizations promoted sport as a technique to entice younger males to the religion in an age when the decline of male church membership was effectively documented. But MMA non secular communities have reshaped muscular Christianity into a brand new stage of high-octane biblical masculinity.
“Jesus didn’t knock,” they declare, referring to the act of submission.
Can violence and writing be mixed?
It’s this notion of “Jesus as a fighter” that’s on the coronary heart of the Christian MMA ethos that Mark Driscoll, a well known US-based evangelical pastor and supporter of MMA, has eagerly embraced.
“I don't suppose there's something cleaner than placing two males in a cage … and simply discovering out which man is best,” Driscoll stated. “And as a pastor, as a Bible trainer, I believe God made males masculine… Males are made for combating, males are made for battle, males are made for dominance.”
Nonetheless, a momentary theological reflection raises a lot of moral difficulties and paradoxes for the theologian or the considerate Christian.
Primary biblical teachings problem the uncritical acceptance and justification of MMA. In accordance with the Bible, individuals are created within the picture of God – the imago Dei – and due to this fact the human character has unbelievable the Aristocracy and dignity in God's eyes. Second, the centrality of the decision to nonviolence in Jesus' instructing appears basically incompatible with MMA. Lastly, if the physique is the temple of the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 6:19), what could be the theological foundation for accepting brutal and intentional violence in opposition to physique and soul (Matthew 6:22-23) in MMA? competitors?
Along with the theological objections to MMA, there’s an abundance of medical proof demonstrating the chance of traumatic mind harm, psychiatric circumstances, concussion, irreversible neurological dysfunction, and even dying. Each the American Medical Affiliation and the British Medical Affiliation have repeatedly referred to as for a ban on boxing and, extra lately, MMA.
In response, proponents of MMA and boxing usually tout the game's “character-building” qualities, suggesting that it will probably promote self-discipline, a powerful work ethic, respect for self and others, and supply “anger administration remedy” for alienated younger males.
These within the pro-MMA (and boxing) camp are additionally fast to level out that deaths in absolute phrases are larger in different high-risk sports activities equivalent to sky diving, rugby, American soccer and horse racing. However what units MMA (and boxing) aside from these different sports activities is that the principle purpose inside the guidelines is to inflict violence on the opponent with a purpose to win. Conversely, whereas a participant enjoying American soccer or rugby could possibly be severely injured (or killed) by the inherent violence of the game, the intention (ideally) is simply to forestall an opponent from advancing into their very own territory.
Nonetheless, there are a lot of contradictions. As we take into account the theological and medical proof and the principle targets of MMA, how can Christian members in MMA use scripture to justify their actions? What does he take into consideration the truth that many different sporting actions are bodily demanding, contain bodily contact and may also help develop character – however don't contain intentionally beating an opponent into submission? How will he reconcile his religion with the well being dangers of this brutal sport: mind bleeds, various ranges of concussions, dying, emotional trauma and hardening of the center?
Some admit it. As Christian MMA champion Scott 'Bam Bam' Sullivan admitted, “combating simply didn't mesh with my prayer life”; MMA fights, he stated, “encourage a brutal mindset.”
Gordon Marino, professor of philosophy at St. Olaf School {and professional} boxing coach, has written extensively on boxing and extra lately MMA. He interviewed boxing champion (and religious Christian) Manny Pacquiao and introduced a theological dilemma: is boxing (MMA) sinful? Marino recalled:
Earlier than a latest battle, I pressed Pacquiao in regards to the obvious contradiction between his devotion to the Godman, who insisted we flip the opposite cheek, and his concussion. There was silence. I used to be afraid I had crossed the road and stated, “I'm sorry if I offended you with that query.” Pac Man replied, “No, that's an excellent query.” I believe it’s unsuitable that we attempt to harm one another, however I additionally suppose that God will forgive us (him and his adversary) as a result of it’s our calling. I may have pressed, “However why would God offer you a calling that was sinful?” however as an alternative I went again and left it at that – ambivalence that’s.
Nonetheless, the ambivalence is misplaced on different non secular boxers and Christian MMA fighters. Pastor John Renken is a contemporary muscle Christian and founding father of a Nashville church referred to as Xtreme Ministries. MMA, he argues, acts as a masculine expression of devotion. It’s a place “the place toes, fist and religion collide”.
Tyrone Siu/Reuters
